Below is a list of Metacritic.com’s top movies during the ten years since it started, 2000-2009. The website has collated reviews of the films, from top professional critics, and given them numerical scores, out of 100, before working out an overall average. To make the list the films needed 7 or more reviews and re-releases and alternate versions are excluded. Also shown is the average site user score that is out of ten.
THE BEST-REVIEWED MOVIES OF THE DECADE, 2000-09
Title
Year
Metascore
Users
1
Pan’s Labyrinth
2006
98
8.3
2
4 Months, 3 Weeks and 2 Days
2008
97
8.0
3
Ratatouille
2007
96
8.6
4
Spirited Away
2002
94
9.3
5
Hurt Locker, The
2009
94
7.6
6
Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King, The
2003
94
8.6
7
Sideways
2004
94
6.1
8
WALL-E
2008
93
8.9
9
Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon
2000
93
7.0
10
35 Shots of Rum
2009
93
7.3
11
Yi Yi (A One and a Two)
2000
92
8.2
12
Diving Bell and the Butterfly, The
2007
92
8.1
13
Class, The
2008
92
6.9
14
There Will Be Blood
2007
92
7.1
15
Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring, The
2001
92
8.4
16
Werckmeister Harmonies
2001
92
7.0
17
Moolaadé
2004
91
7.9
18
Fast Runner, The
2002
91
7.8
19
Triplets of Belleville, The
2003
91
7.8
20
Queen, The
2006
91
6.0
21
Beau Travail
2000
91
7.8
22
Waltz with Bashir
2008
91
8.1
23
No Country for Old Men
2007
91
6.9
24
My Voyage to Italy
2001
90
7.0
25
Bloody Sunday
2002
90
8.4
26
Incredibles, The
2004
90
8.7
27
Before Sunset
2004
90
8.2
28
Almost Famous
2000
90
8.3
29
American Splendor
2003
90
8.0
30
Gosford Park
2001
90
6.1
31
United 93
2006
90
7.5
32
Capturing the Friedmans
2003
90
8.5
33
Persepolis
2007
90
8.1
34
Lost in Translation
2003
89
6.3
35
Best of Youth, The
2005
89
9.1
36
Lives of Others, The
2006
89
9.0
37
Still Walking
2009
89
9.1
38
House of Flying Daggers
2004
89
7.7
39
Man on Wire
2008
89
8.1
40
Borat: Cultural Learnings of America for Make Benefit Glorious Nation of Kazakhstan
2006
89
6.9
41
Finding Nemo
2003
89
8.5
42
Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind
2004
89
8.6
43
No End in Sight
2007
89
8.2
44
Goodbye Solo
2009
89
7.5
45
Letters from Iwo Jima
2006
89
8.1
46
Once
2007
88
8.0
47
Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers, The
2002
88
8.9
48
Ghost World
2001
88
8.4
49
Capote
2005
88
7.9
50
Tulpan
2009
88
5.7
51
Time Out
2002
88
7.2
52
Away from Her
2007
88
8.0
53
Chicken Run
2000
88
7.1
54
Up
2009
88
9.0
55
Y Tu Mamá También
2002
88
7.8
56
Nobody Knows
2005
88
9.0
57
L’Enfant (The Child)
2006
87
8.4
58
Gomorrah
2009
87
6.1
59
Fog of War, The
2003
87
8.7
60
Wallace & Gromit: The Curse of the Were-Rabbit
2005
87
8.2
61
Maria Full of Grace
2004
87
8.4
62
Fateless
2006
87
8.4
63
Brokeback Mountain
2005
87
8.2
64
Tarnation
2004
87
7.3
65
Murderball
2005
87
9.0
66
Grizzly Man
2005
87
6.7
67
Marooned in Iraq
2003
86
7.3
68
Wind Will Carry Us, The
2000
86
8.2
69
Slumdog Millionaire
2008
86
7.9
70
Million Dollar Baby
2004
86
7.8
71
To Be and to Have
2003
86
10.0
72
In the Bedroom
2001
86
7.4
73
I’m Going Home
2002
86
7.0
74
Ten
2003
86
8.3
75
Russian Ark
2002
86
7.1
76
Deliver Us from Evil
2006
86
8.5
77
Beaches of Agnes, The
2009
86
8.2
78
Traffic
2000
86
8.0
79
Under the Sand
2001
86
8.7
80
Talk to Her
2002
86
8.4
81
Our Daily Bread
2006
86
7.7
82
This Is England
2007
86
7.4
83
Son, The
2003
86
7.5
84
Sweet Sixteen
2003
86
8.5
85
Departed, The
2006
86
7.7
86
Ponyo
2009
86
7.6
87
Andy Warhol: A Documentary Film
2006
86
8.0
88
Flight of the Red Balloon, The
2008
86
5.5
89
Before Night Falls
2000
85
9.0
90
Bourne Ultimatum, The
2007
85
7.7
91
Pianist, The
2002
85
8.6
92
You Can Count On Me
2000
85
8.5
93
Children Underground
2001
85
9.8
94
Edge of Heaven, The
2008
85
8.7
95
Savages, The
2007
85
7.4
96
Endurance: Shackleton’s Legendary Antarctic Expedition, The
2001
85
8.2
97
Offside
2007
85
8.6
98
Los Angeles Plays Itself
2004
85
7.8
99
Knocked Up
2007
85
6.4
100
Turtles Can Fly
2005
85
9.4
The list below shows the top 100 films over this period that had a wide cinema release. The reasoning for Metacritic.com publishing this list is for the benefit of the average site visitors who may not have heard of some of the foreign and art-house films in the list above.
THE BEST-REVIEWED WIDE-RELEASE FILMS OF THE DECADE, 2000-09
Title
Year
Metascore
Users
1
Pan’s Labyrinth
2006
98
8.3
2
Ratatouille
2007
96
8.6
3
Spirited Away
2002
94
9.3
4
Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King, The
2003
94
8.6
5
Sideways
2004
94
6.1
6
WALL-E
2008
93
8.9
7
Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon
2000
93
7.0
8
There Will Be Blood
2007
92
7.1
9
Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring, The
2001
92
8.4
10
Queen, The
2006
91
6.0
11
No Country for Old Men
2007
91
6.9
12
Incredibles, The
2004
90
8.7
13
Almost Famous
2000
90
8.3
14
Gosford Park
2001
90
6.1
15
United 93
2006
90
7.5
16
Lost in Translation
2003
89
6.3
17
House of Flying Daggers
2004
89
7.7
18
Borat: Cultural Learnings of America for Make Benefit Glorious Nation of Kazakhstan
The Moving Arts Film Journal is an online publication dedicated to the moving art of film. They aim to preserve the rich history and secure a prosperous future for film as a relevant artistic medium.
The Observer is a British newspaper published on Sundays. In the same place on the political spectrum as its sister papers the Guardian and the Guardian Weekly, whose parent company Guardian Media Group Limited acquired it in 1993, it takes a social liberal or social democratic line on most issues. First published in 1791, it is the world’s oldest Sunday newspaper.
Metacritic is a website that collates reviews of music albums, games, movies, TV shows and DVDs. For each product, a numerical score from each review is obtained and the total is averaged.
Total Film is a British film magazine published 13 times a year by Future Publishing. The magazine was launched in 1997 and offers cinema, DVD and Blu-ray news, reviews and features.
The National Board of Review of Motion Pictures was founded in 1909 in New York City, 14 years after the birth of cinema, to protest New York City Mayor George B. McClellan Jr.’s revocation of moving-picture exhibition licenses on Christmas Eve 1908. Its stated purpose was to endorse films of merit and champion the new “art of the people”, which was transforming America’s cultural life.
Ranker (ranker.com) is a leading digital media company for opinion-based, crowdsourced rankings on just about everything.
Ranker.com’s Best Movies of All-Time
The Best Animated Films Ever
The Best Animated Movies of 2017
The Absolute Funniest Movies Of All Time
The Best Superhero Movies Ever Made
The Best Psychological Thrillers of All Time
The Writers Guild of America is the joint efforts of two different US labor unions representing TV and film writers: The Writers Guild of America, East (WGAE), headquartered in New York City. The Writers Guild of America, West (WGAW), headquartered in Los Angeles.
Senses of Cinema is a quarterly online film magazine founded in 1999 by filmmaker Bill Mousoulis. Based in Melbourne, Australia, Senses of Cinema publishes work by film critics from all over the world, including critical essays, career overviews of the works of key directors, and coverage of many international festivals.
Radio Times is a British weekly television and radio programme listings magazine. It was the world’s first broadcast listings magazine when it was founded in 1923 by John Reith, the then general manager of the BBC. It was published entirely in-house by BBC Magazines from 1937muntil 2011 when the BBC Magazines division was merged into Immediate Media Company.
The Guardian is a British daily newspaper currently in tabloid format. It was known from 1821 until 1959 as the Manchester Guardian. Along with its sister papers The Observer and the Guardian Weekly, The Guardian is part of the Guardian Media Group, owned by the Scott Trust.
The Online Film Critics Society (OFCS) is an international professional association of online film journalists, historians and scholars who publish their work on the World Wide Web. The organisation was founded in January 1997 by Harvey Karten, an early online critic who discovered that membership in the New York Film Critics Circle was open only to journalists working for newspapers and magazines.
The Motion Picture Editors Guild (MPEG) is the guild that represents freelance and staff motion picture film and television editors and other post-production professionals and story analysts throughout the United States.
The London Film Critics’ Circle is the name by which the Film Section of The Critics’ Circle is known internationally. Film critics first became eligible for membership of the Circle in 1926. The Film section now has more than 120 members drawn from publications and the broadcasting media throughout the United Kingdom.
Roger Joseph Ebert was an American film critic, historian, journalist, screenwriter, and author. He was a film critic for the Chicago Sun-Times from 1967 until his death in 2013. In 1975, Ebert became the first film critic to win the Pulitzer Prize for Criticism. Ebert compiled “best of the year” movie lists beginning in 1967 until 2012, thereby helping provide an overview of his critical preferences.
The Holy See also referred to as the See of Rome, is the ecclesiastical jurisdiction of the Catholic Church in Rome, the episcopal see of the Pope, and an independent sovereign entity. It serves as the central point of reference for the Catholic Church everywhere and the focal point of communion due to its position as the pre-eminent episcopal see of the universal church. Today, it is responsible for the governance of all Catholics, organised in their Particular Churches, Patriarchates and religious institutes.
Rate Your Music is an online collaborative metadata database of musical and non-musical releases and films which can be catalogued, rated and reviewed by users.
rateyourmusic.com/films/chart 1000 All-time films
TV Guide Magazine (the August 8-14, 1998 issue) offered their picks for the perfect flicks to catch on television or to watch on one’s VCR (or DVD player). From hundreds of the magazine’s four-star titles, they chose the movies that played particularly well on the small screen and held up to repeated viewings.
Blockbuster LLC, formerly Blockbuster Entertainment, Inc., and also known as Blockbuster Video or simply Blockbuster, was an American-based provider of home movie and video game rental services through video rental shops, DVD-by-mail, streaming, video on demand, and cinema theatre.
British-Irish writer director Martin McDonagh (In Bruges, Seven Psychopaths) first conceived the idea for what became the darkly comic drama Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri while travelling through the south east corner of the United States, nearly twenty years ago, and seeing billboards about an unsolved crime. McDonagh stated in an interview with Christina Radish of Collider.com, “the rage that put a bunch of billboards like that up was palpable and stayed with me.” He never knew the story behind the boards but they inspired the film’s fictional scenario. “Once I decided, in my head, that it was a mother, everything fell into place.”
McDonagh wrote the part of the grieving mother, Mildred Hayes, with the academy award winning Frances McDormand in mind and although he had to convince her that the character be a mother rather than grandmother (McDormand is now 60), she went on to deliver arguably the most compelling performance of her career (or at least worthy of comparison with her role in Fargo).
Buy (watch online) or with HBO (free trial followed by subscription
DVD
Screenplay
Original Soundtrack
Movie Poster Limited Print Photo Size 11×17
Movie Poster Limited Print Photo Size 24×36
13.5×20 Inch Movie Promo Poster
The film begins with the foul mouthed Mildred renting three long abandoned billboards to call attention to the rape and murder of her teenage daughter Angela seven months previously and the seemingly lackadaisical efforts of local law enforcement to solve the case. She cares little that the billboards upset the townspeople, including popular Sheriff Bill Willoughby (Woody Harrelson), whose name appears on the third board, and officer Jason Dixon (Sam Rockwell), a dim-witted racist. With most in the town aware that Willoughby has terminal pancreatic cancer, Mildred and her depressed son Robbie (Lucas Hedges) are harassed and threatened, but she stands firm, much to her son’s annoyance.
CAST
Frances McDormand as Mildred
Woody Harrelson as Willoughby
Sam Rockwell as Dixon
Caleb Landry Jones as Red Welby
Kerry Condon as Pamela
Darrell Britt-Gibson as Jerome
Abbie Cornish as Anne
Lucas Hedges as Robbie
Željko Ivanek as Desk Sergeant
John Hawkes as Charlie
Peter Dinklage as James
Samara Weaving as Penelope
Clarke Peters as Abercrombie
Like McDormand, Sam Rockwell also had his part written especially for him. Rockwell, who has mentioned he spent time with Missouri police officers in preparation for his role, plays probably the most controversial character in the piece. Dixon is the one who goes through the biggest transformation and McDonagh has been asked about such a bigoted character being portrayed sympathetically. There’s no doubting that however bad the behaviour of the hapless officer becomes, it will be almost impossible for some viewers to dislike the engaging Rockwell and not long for Dixon to redeem himself. In fact, it becomes one of the main elements that drives the unpredictable narrative and has gone on to bring about a Media backlash against the film (more about that later).
Along with Rockwell, Woody Harrelson has also been nominated for a best supporting Oscar for his role. Harrelson’s Police Chief Willoughby is a family man with two young daughters and is actually sympathetic to Mildred’s situation despite her obnoxious and dangerous behaviour (such as assaulting her dentist with his drill) and initially appearing indifferent to the chief’s terminal cancer.
However good Rockwell and Harrison are, this is still McDormand’s film and she could well be on her way to bagging another Oscar for her unforgettable performance. Thank goodness her acclaimed film maker husband Joel Coen convinced her to take the part regardless of McDonagh’s decision for the character. McDormand told the New York Times Magazine she took inspiration for Mildred from John Wayne, which in turn eventually inspired Sam Rockwell to take inspiration for Dixon from Wayne’s co-star in The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance, played by Lee Marvin, noting that he wanted to make his character “the exact opposite” of Mildred. (he was also apparently channelling Barney Rubble during his portrayal!)
There’s also significant parts for Peter Drinklage (Game of Thrones), whose character has a thing for Mildred, Caleb Landry Jones as Red, who rents her the billboards (and is a target of Dixon’s hatred), the excellent John Hawkes as Mildred’s abusive ex-husband (who’s now in a relationship with a 19 year old) and Clarke Peters (The Wire).
Some in the media have objected to what they see as a powerful story of a grieving mother being undermined by the attempted redemption of a white racist character. McDonagh has admitted to playing with the audiences allegiances, turning our sympathies from a woman who shows hate due to the lack of justice for her daughter to a man who hates due to ignorance and upbringing. Everyone views art in their own subjective fashion and plenty will reach the end seeing little that’s redeeming and may instead focus on how a woman deals with grief and anger when a crime is unsolved while also examining where hatred and bigotry come from and the violence they can fuel.
While McDonagh was snubbed for Best Director and the Dixon backlash shows no sign of abating, there is a nomination for the Best Picture Oscar and whatever the outcome the film will stand as his most notable production so far. While, it has all the hallmarks of his prior filmography, violence (often brutal), profanity, dark humour, witty and biting dialogue and clever plot twists, it’s a strong female lead character (previously missing from McDonagh’s cinema work) who makes the biggest impression. It’s also important to praise the work of the director, for he has crafted a surprisingly upbeat film from a bleak premise and despite all the fighting, rage and swearing it’s the quiet contemplative and cinematic moments that really make the drama hit home.
The emotive score is by Carter Burwell, who also worked with Martin McDonagh on In Bruges and Seven Psychopaths. The well used soundtrack also features songs by Joan Baez, Monsters of Folk, Townes Van Zandt, and the Four Tops.
As a male in his 30’s who normally enjoys action films I’d expect to take some level of enjoyment from Gerard Butler’s latest offering. However, sitting through director Christian Gudegast’s misguided and derivative macho heist thriller was one of the most underwhelming experiences I’ve had in a cinema for several years. It was hardly surprising to see an elderly gent in the row in front asleep through most of the turgid 2 hours and 20 minutes.
The film, that’s not without ambition and has plenty of nods to past heist movies, opens with a robbery that goes terribly wrong. The thieves attempt to break into an armoured truck outside a coffee shop but end up killing all the guards and engaging in a full on shootout with Police officers. With one of the robbers dead and plenty of law enforcers also, the gang make off with the empty truck. Now being cop killers they are under the microscope of LA’s Major Crimes Unit led by snarling Sheriff Nick “Big Nick” O’Brien (Butler, who’s also a producer), the sort of generic troubled cop we’ve seen so many times before. His life is falling apart as his wife’s leaving him (and taking the two children) and he has a drink and drug problem. He comes across as obnoxious, sleazy and menacing (particularly to any future partner of his wife) but as the star of the film he is, of course, the one cop who really cares! (Think Bruce Willis in the Die Hard films but without the wit and likeability).
Unrated Version (Buy, watch online)
Blu-ray
The group of ridiculously beefed up and mostly former servicemen thieves, are led by ex-marine Ray Merrimen (Pablo Schreiber, once brilliant in The Wire) who’s already led his crew to plenty of robberies and appears to have occasional moments of conscience when it comes to people being unnecessarily killed. His main lieutenant is none other than everyone’s favourite drug dealer turned rapper Curtis James Jackson III or more famously known by his nickname “50 Cent.” (pictured below) Like Big Nick he is a loving father, which is evident when he scares his daughter’s prom date witless!
If it hadn’t already become clear that the film’s makers were big admirer’s of one particular Michael Mann film, then there were no doubts remaining when Big Nick and Merrimen come face to face in some laughably illogical and contrived scenes, which fail to come close to the well scripted and memorable exchanges between De Niro’s thief and Al Pacino’s cop in Heat.
CAST
Gerard Butler as Nick “Big Nick” O’Brien
O’Shea Jackson Jr. as Donnie
50 Cent as Levi Enson
Pablo Schreiber as Ray Merrimen
Evan Jones as Bosco
Cooper Andrews as Mack
Maurice Compte as Benny ‘Borracho’ Megalob
Kaiwi Lyman-Mersereau as Tony Z Zapata
Dawn Olivieri as Debbie O’Brien
Lewis Tan as Secret Service Lobby Guard #1
Mo McRae as Gus Henderson
Brian Van Holt as Murph
Max Holloway as Bas
Jay Dobyns as Wolfgang
Alix Lapri as Maloa
Matthew Cornwell as Joseph
The finale may again remind some of Mann’s film and its well crafted shootout scenes but it feels almost insulting to be comparing the sluggish and implausible Den of Thieves to the memorable crime drama from 1995. The film’s momentum has long gone by the time of the final twist. I decided to steer away from 0/5 out of sympathy for Butler (who has brief moments of strong acting) and for Schreiber and his once promising career. sjb